A payroll system audit checks how your payroll is set up, not just whether last month’s pay run balanced. That difference matters, because a wrong setting does not cause one error. It causes the same error in every pay run until someone finds it. This checklist covers what to review in your payroll system, in the order we work through it with Australian employers.
Short answer: a payroll system audit reviews employee records, pay rates and award setup, pay categories, super, leave, Single Touch Payroll, terminations, payslips and who can change what. Do one at least once a year, and again after the 1 July rate changes, a system change, a new award or enterprise agreement, or a change in who runs payroll.
Why payroll system audits matter more now
Three changes have raised the stakes for Australian employers:
- Underpayment laws: since 1 January 2025, intentionally underpaying employees is a criminal offence. Honest mistakes are not covered by the criminal offence, but civil penalties can still apply to underpayments that were not deliberate.
- Payday Super: since 1 July 2026, super must reach the employee’s fund within seven business days after payday, calculated on qualifying earnings. That added new settings to get right in every payroll system.
- More complex pay: more awards, more allowances and more casual and part-time staff mean more rules for the system to apply correctly.
A payroll audit that only checks the totals of a few pay runs will not find a wrong setting. A system audit will.
If you want to know how a full payroll audit is run from start to finish, including remediation, read our payroll audit guide. This article is the payroll audit checklist for the system itself.
What to gather before you start
- the pay category list, with the tax, super and STP settings for each category
- an employee details report showing employment type, award, classification and pay rate
- the awards and enterprise agreements that apply, with the current pay guides
- pay run reports for the last three months
- super batch reports and fund confirmations since 1 July 2026
- leave balance and leave accrual reports
- a list of every user with access to payroll, and what they can change
The payroll system audit checklist
1. Employee records
- Every employee has the right employment type: full-time, part-time or casual.
- Start dates are correct, because they drive leave, probation and length of service.
- Each employee is linked to the right award and classification for the work they actually do.
- Part-time employees have their agreed regular hours recorded, as most awards require.
- Tax file number declarations and super choice details are complete.
- Changes to bank details need a second check before the next pay run.
2. Pay rates and award setup
- Award rates were updated from the first full pay period on or after 1 July. The national minimum wage rose to $26.44 per hour from 1 July 2026. Our summary of 2026–27 payroll changes lists the other new figures.
- Allowances, penalty rates, overtime and casual loading are set up for each award you use.
- Sample shifts give the same result as the award pay guide, including evenings, weekends, public holidays and overtime.
- Salaried employees covered by an award are checked against what the award would have paid for the hours they actually work.
- Base rates in any enterprise agreement are not below the current award base rates.
3. Pay categories
- Every pay category has the right tax treatment.
- Every pay category is mapped to the right Single Touch Payroll Phase 2 payment type.
- The super setting on each category matches qualifying earnings.
- Leave accrues on the right categories, and not on the wrong ones.
- Pay categories created or copied since 1 July have been checked, not just the old ones.
4. Superannuation
- Super is calculated at 12% of qualifying earnings.
- There is a super batch for every pay run, approved early enough to reach funds within seven business days.
- Fund details are complete for every employee, with stapled fund requests made for new starters who did not choose a fund.
- Salary sacrifice arrangements are set up and reported correctly.
- Returned and rejected contributions since 1 July have all been fixed and resent.
5. Leave
- Annual leave and personal or carer’s leave accrue at the right rates for full-time and part-time employees.
- Casual employees do not accrue paid annual or personal leave.
- Leave loading is paid where the award or contract requires it.
- Long service leave settings match the rules in each state where you employ people.
- Leave balances look reasonable, with no negative or unusually large balances left unexplained.
6. Single Touch Payroll and tax
- Every pay run has been reported through Single Touch Payroll without errors.
- Last financial year was finalised for every employee.
- Tax withholding settings match each employee’s declaration.
- Payroll tax thresholds and grouping have been checked for each state where you employ people.
7. Terminations
- Notice and redundancy pay follow the National Employment Standards and the award.
- Unused annual leave, and leave loading where it applies, is paid out correctly on termination.
- Employment termination payments are set up with the right tax treatment.
- Final pay is made on time under the award or agreement.
8. Payslips and records
- Payslips go out within one working day of payday, with every detail Fair Work requires.
- Time and wages records are kept for seven years and can be produced quickly.
- Records of hours are kept for casual and irregular part-time employees paid by the hour, and for overtime.
9. Access and approvals
- Only the people who need it can change pay rates, pay categories and bank details.
- Pay runs are approved by someone other than the person who prepared them.
- The payroll audit log is reviewed for changes nobody can explain.
- Former staff and old advisers no longer have access.
Test the settings, do not just read them
Reading a setting tells you what someone intended. Testing it tells you what the system does. For each award you use, run a few sample shifts through the system: a weekday, a Saturday, a Sunday, a public holiday and an overtime shift. Compare the result with the pay guide. Do the same for one termination and one leave payment. Most setup errors show up in the first few tests. If your awards are complex, such as SCHADS or several awards in one business, our award interpretation service can set up and test the rules for you.
What to do with what you find
- Fix the setting first, so the next pay run is right.
- Work out what is owed, going back to when the setting changed.
- Pay back underpayments and super shortfalls quickly. For super, the ATO’s first-year Payday Super approach treats employers who fix problems promptly as low risk.
- Write down what you found, what you fixed and when. A clear record shows you acted in good faith.
- Get advice if the amounts are large or the problem goes back years.
How often to run a payroll system audit
Once a year is the minimum. Audit again after:
- the 1 July award and minimum wage increases
- a move to new payroll software
- a new award, a new enterprise agreement or a restructure
- a change in who runs your payroll
- any pay error that reached an employee
Want an expert to run the checks?
Our Payroll Health Check is a flat $250, free when you sign up for at least one Employment Star service. Each review is run by an Employment Hero payroll specialist. Full payroll system audits are quoted at a fixed price after a short scoping call, or charged from $195 per hour ex-GST. Call 02 7803 7879.
Frequently asked questions
What is a payroll system audit?
A payroll system audit is a review of how your payroll software is set up: employee records, award rules, pay categories, super, leave, Single Touch Payroll, terminations and access. It finds settings that cause the same error in every pay run.
How is a payroll system audit different from a payroll audit?
A payroll audit usually checks past pay runs for errors. A payroll system audit checks the settings that produce those pay runs. A full payroll compliance audit does both: it tests the settings, then checks past pay against them.
How often should we audit our payroll system?
At least once a year, and again after the 1 July rate changes, a system change, a new award or enterprise agreement, or a change in who runs payroll.
How long does a payroll system audit take?
For a small business with one award, a review can take a few days. Businesses with several awards, entities or sites take longer, so we scope the work and agree a fixed price first.
How do I audit my payroll system for underpayments?
Check the settings first: award coverage, classifications, pay rates, pay categories and super. Then run sample shifts through the system and compare the results with the award pay guide, and check recent pay runs against the corrected settings. If you find underpayments, fix the setting, work out what is owed, pay it back promptly and keep a record. If the amounts are large, get advice before you contact the Fair Work Ombudsman.
This article is general information only. Check your situation with the Fair Work Ombudsman, the ATO or a qualified adviser.
About Employment Star — We are a certified Employment Hero implementation partner based in Parramatta, NSW, working with small and medium businesses across Australia. We provide payroll consulting and training, payroll audits, outsourced payroll and Employment Hero setup, including NDIS and SCHADS Award payroll.
Published 16 November 2026 · Last updated 16 November 2026
