Most payroll problems do not announce themselves. Pay runs go out on time, staff are paid something close to the right amount, and the errors sit quietly in the setup until an employee, the ATO or the Fair Work Ombudsman finds them.
This guide is for Australian business owners, finance managers and payroll officers who are wondering whether their payroll needs a second pair of eyes. It covers the eight warning signs that most often lead businesses to payroll consulting, what a payroll review actually covers, what a payroll consultant costs, and when training or outsourcing is the better answer.
The short answer: you need a payroll consultant when your payroll produces results you cannot fully explain or check yourself. The most common signs are pay queries from staff, manual fixes in every pay run, super that is not yet paid with every pay run, award or system changes that nobody has tested, and payroll knowledge held by one person. A payroll health check is usually the first step, and it costs far less than correcting an underpayment after the fact.
Why payroll needs an expert review more often now
Australian payroll has changed more in the last two years than in the decade before. Three changes in particular have raised the cost of getting it wrong:
- Payday Super. Since 1 July 2026, super must reach each employee’s fund within 7 business days of payday, and it is calculated on qualifying earnings. Payroll that still pays super quarterly, or on the old earnings base, is out of step with the law.
- Criminal underpayment laws. Since 1 January 2025, intentionally underpaying wages or entitlements can be a criminal offence. Honest mistakes are not covered, but they still have to be found, fixed and back-paid.
- Annual award increases. Minimum wages and award rates rise from the first full pay period on or after 1 July each year. The national minimum wage is now $26.44 an hour, and every rate, allowance and penalty built on last year’s figures needs updating. Our guide to the 2026–27 payroll changes lists the current figures.
Enforcement is rising too. The Fair Work Ombudsman recovered $453 million in unpaid wages and entitlements for more than 181,000 workers in 2025–26, about 27% more than the year before, and the regulator nearly doubled its proactive investigations over the same period.
What does a payroll consultant do?
A payroll consultant checks, fixes and improves the way your business pays people. A payroll processor runs each pay cycle, and a software help desk explains how features work. A consultant looks at whether your payroll is producing the right answer, and why. Payroll consulting usually includes:
- auditing pay runs against the awards, enterprise agreements and contracts that apply
- correcting award interpretation and pay rule settings at the source
- checking super, STP Phase 2 reporting and leave calculations
- calculating back-pay when something has gone wrong
- working out complex payments such as long service leave, redundancy and termination pays
- documenting how your payroll is set up and training the people who run it
That last point is why many payroll consultants offer payroll consulting and training together. Fixing the setup solves today’s problem; training your team stops it coming back.
8 signs you need a payroll consultant
1. Staff are questioning their pay
One query is normal. A steady stream of questions about weekend rates, overtime, leave balances or missing allowances usually points to a pay rule that is set up incorrectly, and if one employee has noticed, others on the same rule are probably affected too. If you have already found an underpayment, the question is no longer whether there is a problem, but how far back it goes.
What a consultant checks: the pay rules behind the queries, every employee on the same award or classification, and how many pay periods are affected.
2. Pay runs need manual fixes to come out right
If someone adjusts hours, adds allowances by hand or overrides rates before each pay run is approved, the system is not doing the work it should. Manual fixes rely on one person remembering every exception, every time. They are also hard to check later, because the records no longer show how each figure was worked out.
What a consultant checks: which manual adjustments are made each cycle, and which can be built into the system as automatic pay rules.
3. Super is not yet paid with every pay run
Under Payday Super, contributions must reach the employee’s fund within 7 business days of payday. Businesses that still batch super monthly or quarterly, or that relied on the Small Business Superannuation Clearing House, which has now closed, need to change both their process and their payroll settings. Late super attracts the super guarantee charge, which adds extra amounts on top of the super owed.
What a consultant checks: that super is calculated on qualifying earnings, paid with every pay run and reaching each fund inside the deadline.
4. Award rates, classifications or agreements have changed
Award rates rise every July, awards are varied during the year, and employees move between classifications as their duties change. A new enterprise agreement brings its own rates and conditions, and it must leave every award-covered employee better off overall than the award. If nobody has confirmed that your system picked up the latest changes, check before the next pay run. Getting award interpretation right is where most underpayments start or stop.
What a consultant checks: current award rates, allowances and penalties against your settings, classifications against the work people actually do, and agreement rates against the award.
5. STP reports, super funds or the ATO do not match your payroll
Every pay run is reported to the ATO through Single Touch Payroll (STP) Phase 2, with pay broken down by type, such as overtime, allowances and paid leave. Warning signs include STP lodgements that fail or need correcting, employees whose year-to-date figures in their ATO online account do not match their pay slips, and contributions rejected or returned by super funds. These are usually setup problems, and they repeat every pay run until the setup is fixed.
What a consultant checks: pay category mapping for STP Phase 2, year-to-date reconciliation, and employees’ super fund and member details.
6. You changed payroll systems and nobody has checked the setup since
Moving to new payroll software is a common point for errors to creep in. Award rules are rebuilt from scratch, leave balances and year-to-date figures are migrated, and the people who set it up move on once it goes live. If your implementation did not include parallel pay runs, or you are still working around problems from go-live, an independent review will show what was configured and what was missed. Our payroll implementation guide explains what a complete setup should include.
What a consultant checks: the configuration against your awards, migrated balances against your old system, and any past pays that need correcting.
7. Payroll depends on one person
If one payroll officer is the only person who knows how pay runs work, which exceptions to apply and where the workarounds are, your business carries a key-person risk. A resignation, illness or extended leave can leave you unable to pay people correctly. Rainbow Club faced exactly this when their payroll officer resigned with only weeks to hand over, taking a great deal of undocumented payroll knowledge with them.
What a consultant checks: how each pay run is processed, what is documented, and what someone else would need to run payroll tomorrow.
8. Your business has grown or changed shape
Payroll that worked for ten salaried staff often struggles at forty employees across shifts, awards and locations. Growth brings new awards and classifications, casual and part-time staff, extra entities or ABNs, employees in other states, payroll tax thresholds and, for disability and community service providers, the complexity of the SCHADS Award. Each change adds rules that a simple setup was never built to handle.
What a consultant checks: whether your awards, entities, cost centres and payroll tax obligations are set up for the business you are now, not the one you were.
How many signs apply to you?
| Signs that apply | What we suggest |
|---|---|
| None | Review payroll once a year, and check your settings after each 1 July increase. |
| One or two | Book a payroll health check to confirm the settings behind those signs. |
| Three or more, or any confirmed underpayment | Arrange a full payroll audit, including back-pay calculations where needed. |
What a payroll review covers
A good payroll review looks at both the numbers and the setup that produced them. An Employment Star review typically covers:
- Award coverage and classification: the right award, agreement or contract for each employee, and the right classification for the work they do.
- Pay rules: base rates, penalty rates, overtime, allowances, minimum engagements and loadings.
- Superannuation: the earnings base, the rate, the funds and the timing under Payday Super.
- STP Phase 2 pay category mapping and year-to-date reconciliation.
- Leave: accrual rates, balances, leave loading and long service leave under the relevant state law.
- Terminations: final pays, unused leave and redundancy calculations.
- Records and pay slips: pay slips issued within one working day of payday, and employee records kept for 7 years.
- System access and process: who can change pay settings, who approves pay runs, and whether the process is documented.
The outcome should be a written, prioritised list of findings: what is wrong, what it will take to fix, and what to do first. For a closer look at how an audit runs, see our payroll audit guide.
What does a payroll consultant cost?
Payroll consulting is usually priced in one of three ways: a fixed fee for a defined review, an hourly rate for advice and calculations, or a monthly fee if you hand payroll over completely. Here is how Employment Star prices each service:
| Service | What it covers | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Payroll check | A 30-minute call to talk through your payroll and the signs above | Free |
| Payroll Health Check | A review of your payroll settings and process, with the risks found and the improvements to make | A flat $250, free when you sign up for at least one Employment Star service |
| Full payroll audit | A detailed review across awards, pay runs and super, with back-pay calculations where needed | Fixed price, quoted after a short scoping call |
| Consulting and training | Complex leave and redundancy calculations, end-of-year reconciliations, and training on your own payroll | From $195 per hour ex-GST |
| Payroll cover | Short-term or backup cover when your payroll officer is away | From $195 per hour ex-GST |
| Outsourced payroll | Employment Star runs your payroll, including Payday Super and STP Phase 2 | From $450 ex-GST per month, quoted for your business |
The cost of an audit depends on the number of awards and agreements, the number of employees and entities, how many pay periods need checking, the quality of your records, and whether back-pay has to be calculated. Whatever the price, agree the scope in writing before work starts, so you know exactly what you are paying for.
When comparing quotes, look past the hourly rate. A provider who processes pay runs is not the same as a payroll consultant who can interpret awards, explain every difference and fix the configuration at its source.
Payroll consultant, payroll training or outsourced payroll?
Each one solves a different problem:
- A payroll consultant suits businesses that want to keep payroll in-house but need it checked, fixed or set up for a change.
- Payroll training suits teams that run payroll every cycle but need more confidence with awards, Payday Super, STP Phase 2 or their payroll software.
- Outsourced payroll suits businesses that want payroll off their plate entirely, with specialists running every pay cycle.
Many businesses start with a review, fix what it finds and train their team, and then decide whether to keep payroll in-house or outsource it.
What to do if you think you have underpaid staff
Act quickly, and keep a record of each step:
- Work out which employees, pay rules and pay periods are affected.
- Fix the setting that caused the problem before the next pay run, so the error stops growing.
- Calculate back-pay, including super, for every affected pay period.
- Pay what is owed, explain the correction to the employees affected, and keep the calculations.
- Get advice on whether to contact the Fair Work Ombudsman, particularly for larger or long-running underpayments.
Only intentional underpayment can be a criminal offence, and small business employers who follow the Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code are protected from criminal referral. Finding and fixing errors early is the best protection for any business.
How Employment Star can help
Employment Star provides payroll consulting and training for Australian employers, including complex NDIS and SCHADS Award payroll. We are a certified Employment Hero implementation partner based in Parramatta, working with businesses across Australia. We audit pay runs, correct award interpretation at the source, calculate back-pay, set up Payday Super and STP Phase 2, and train your team on your own pay runs, not generic examples.
Every review ends with a written, prioritised list of findings, so you know exactly what to fix first.
Not sure whether you need a payroll consultant?
Book a free 30-minute payroll check and we will tell you which of these signs apply and what to do next.
02 7803 7879 · info@employmentstar.com.au
This article is general information only and does not constitute legal, tax or financial advice. Obligations vary by business, industry and applicable modern award. Check your circumstances with the ATO, the Fair Work Ombudsman, or a qualified adviser.
Frequently asked questions
What does a payroll consultant do?
A payroll consultant reviews and improves how a business pays its people. They audit pay runs against awards and agreements, correct system settings, check super and STP Phase 2 reporting, calculate back-pay and complex payments, and train payroll staff.
How much does a payroll consultant cost in Australia?
Payroll consulting is usually priced as a fixed fee for a defined review, an hourly rate for advice, or a monthly fee for outsourced payroll. At Employment Star, consulting starts at $195 per hour ex-GST, full audits are quoted at a fixed price after a short scoping call, and the Payroll Health Check is a flat $250, free when you sign up for at least one of our services.
How often should payroll be reviewed?
At least once a year, and after any major change: the annual award increase from 1 July, a new payroll system, a new enterprise agreement, or a significant change in headcount, entities or locations.
Is payroll consulting the same as outsourced payroll?
No. A payroll consultant reviews, fixes and advises while your team keeps running payroll. With outsourced payroll, a specialist provider runs every pay cycle for you. Many businesses use a consultant first, then decide whether to outsource.
Do I need a payroll consultant if I already use payroll software?
Payroll software calculates what it is set up to calculate. If the award rules, pay categories or super settings are wrong, the software repeats the error in every pay run. A consultant checks that the setup matches your awards and the law.
What is an HR payroll consultant?
An HR payroll consultant advises on both people matters and pay. HR covers areas such as contracts, policies and performance, while payroll covers awards, rates, super, tax and leave. Having both in one place helps when an HR decision, such as a classification change or a new agreement, affects pay.
About Employment Star — We’re a certified Employment Hero implementation partner based in Parramatta, NSW, working with small and medium businesses across Australia. We provide payroll consulting and training, payroll audits, outsourced payroll and Employment Hero setup, including NDIS and SCHADS Award payroll.
Published 10 November 2026 · Last updated 10 November 2026
