Fraud Blocker

Should you outsource payroll or use payroll software? A guide for Australian SMBs

Most small and medium businesses in Australia reach the same question at some point: should we keep running payroll ourselves on payroll software, or outsource payroll to a specialist? Payroll outsourcing has become a common choice for Australian SMBs, but it is not right for everyone. It often gets framed as software against a service. In practice, the real question is who runs the software, and who is responsible for getting each pay right.

Short answer: payroll software calculates pay from the rules you give it. Someone still has to set those rules up, keep award rates current, check timesheets, run each pay, pay super within seven business days, report through Single Touch Payroll and answer staff questions. Software on its own suits businesses with simple pay and a trained person who has time. Outsourced payroll suits businesses with awards, shift work, casuals, or payroll that depends on one busy person. Many businesses use both: their own software, run by an outsourced payroll team.

What payroll software does, and what it does not do

Good payroll software is essential. It calculates pay from the pay rates and award rules you set up, produces payslips, reports each pay run to the ATO through Single Touch Payroll, pays super, tracks leave and gives you reports.

What software does not do is decide anything. It does not work out which award covers each employee or which classification they belong in. It does not know that a rate has changed unless someone updates it. It does not check whether a timesheet is right, chase a rejected super contribution, or notice that a new allowance was set up with the wrong super setting. Employment Hero, for example, applies award rules very well, but it applies the rules it has been given. If the setup is wrong, every pay run repeats the same mistake.

What outsourced payroll services cover

When you outsource payroll, a specialist team runs the pay cycle for you. At Employment Star, our outsourced payroll services include:

  • pay runs and payslips, on your pay cycle
  • modern award and enterprise agreement interpretation
  • leave, terminations and final pay
  • Single Touch Payroll reporting
  • super paid with every pay run, within the Payday Super deadline
  • payroll reports for you and your accountant

Our outsourced payroll runs on Employment Hero. If you already use it, we work inside your account. If you do not, we set up Employment Hero Payroll first and then take over the pay cycle.

Outsourced payroll and payroll software compared

What payroll software does compared with outsourced payroll services
Payroll software, run in-houseOutsourced payroll on your software
Who runs each payYour employee or the ownerA payroll specialist, with your approval
Award and rate updatesYour team must track and apply themThe provider tracks and applies them
Payday Super deadlinesYour team approves super batches and fixes rejectionsThe provider does this each pay run
Questions from staff about payYour team answers themThe provider answers them, or helps you to
Cover for leave or resignationsYou need a trained backupCovered by the provider’s team
CostSoftware subscription plus staff time and trainingSoftware subscription plus a monthly fee
ControlFull control, full responsibilityYou approve each pay; the provider does the work
Best suited toSimple pay, few employees, a trained person with timeAwards, shifts, casuals, growth, or one-person risk

Compare the full cost, not only the subscription

Payroll software is usually priced per employee per month, which makes it look cheap next to an outsourced fee. The subscription is only part of the cost of doing payroll in-house. A fair comparison includes:

  • Time: hours spent on each pay run, plus time on timesheets, super batches, leave, STP corrections and staff questions. Multiply by the number of pay runs a year and the hourly cost of the person doing it.
  • Training: keeping that person current with award changes, Payday Super and Single Touch Payroll.
  • Cover: what happens when that person is on leave, sick or resigns.
  • Errors: back pay, super guarantee charge and the time spent fixing mistakes. Since 1 January 2025, intentionally underpaying employees is a criminal offence, and civil penalties can apply to underpayments even when they are mistakes.

Outsourced payroll at Employment Star starts from $450 ex-GST per month, for businesses anywhere in Australia. It is a flat monthly fee, not a per-employee rate, based on your headcount, pay frequency and complexity, such as the number of awards, entities and pay cycles.

Signs software alone is enough

  • You have a small team on simple salaries, with one award or none.
  • Someone in your business knows payroll well and has time for it every pay run.
  • A second person is trained to run payroll if the first is away.
  • Your pay runs rarely need manual fixes, and staff rarely question their pay.

Signs you should outsource payroll

Small business owner reviewing payroll with an outsourced payroll adviser
  • Your staff are covered by more than one award or an enterprise agreement.
  • You roster shifts with penalty rates, overtime and casual loading.
  • Payroll depends on one person, or on the owner working late at night.
  • You have found errors or paid back pay in the last year.
  • Super batches, rejections or STP corrections are falling behind under Payday Super.
  • Your business is growing, opening new sites or adding entities.

If several of these apply, read our guide to the 8 signs your payroll needs an expert review.

There is a middle option

Payroll outsourcing does not have to be all or nothing. Some businesses keep running payroll themselves and bring in help at set points:

  • a Payroll Health Check, a flat $250 review of your setup, free when you sign up for at least one Employment Star service
  • payroll training for the person running pay, from $195 per hour ex-GST
  • short-term cover while your payroll person is on leave, where we step into your system and hand it back when they return

Questions to ask before you outsource payroll in Australia

  1. Will you work inside our existing payroll system, and who owns the data?
  2. Who checks award coverage and classifications, and how often?
  3. How do you make sure super reaches funds within seven business days?
  4. How do we approve each pay run, and what is the cut-off?
  5. What is included in the fee, and what costs extra?
  6. How do you handle terminations, back pay and out-of-cycle payments?
  7. What happens if we decide to bring payroll back in-house?

Want a straight answer for your business?

Tell us your headcount, awards and pay frequency and we will tell you whether outsourcing makes sense, and what it would cost. See our outsourced payroll services or call 02 7803 7879.

Frequently asked questions

It usually is when your pay involves awards, shift penalties or casual staff, or when payroll depends on one busy person. The outsourced fee is higher than a software subscription, but once you add staff time, training, cover for leave and the cost of errors, outsourcing often costs about the same or less. For a small team on simple salaries with a trained person in-house, software alone may be enough.

No. You still approve every pay run, and with Employment Star the payroll stays in your own Employment Hero account, so you can see everything at any time.

Yes. We work inside your existing Employment Hero account. If your setup needs fixing first, we fix it before we take over the pay cycle.

At Employment Star, outsourced payroll starts from $450 ex-GST per month. The fee is fixed monthly and depends on headcount, pay frequency, the number of awards and entities, and how many pay cycles you run.

The legal obligations to pay employees correctly stay with you as the employer. A specialist provider reduces the risk by running payroll correctly and keeping it current, and is responsible under its agreement with you for the work it does.

This article is general information only. Check your situation with a qualified adviser.

About Employment Star — We are a certified Employment Hero implementation partner based in Parramatta, NSW, working with small and medium businesses across Australia. We provide payroll consulting and training, payroll audits, outsourced payroll and Employment Hero setup, including NDIS and SCHADS Award payroll.

Published 13 November 2026 · Last updated 13 November 2026

Need HR off your plate?

We handle contracts, awards, policies and compliance for Australian small and medium businesses. No lock-in, no per-employee fees.

Payroll running late?

Managed payroll, including Payday Super and STP Phase 2, for a fixed monthly fee quoted for your business.

Employment Hero set up properly

We are a certified Employment Hero implementation partner. Fixed price from $2,340 ex-GST, live in 14 business days.

Related posts